In the early 1990s, Pomona College began planning to replace a cramped, plain building that had served as its campus center for decades. The Smith Campus Center, which was opened in 1999 and costs $18.3 million during construction, ended up being ignored by students. After tweaking things and achieving little results, the college decided to hire SmithGroup to make major renovations on the center. This article describes the extreme makeover made for the Pomona College campus center.