Online learning and assessment have become a major concern for educators in the field of education due to the many challenges they present. The coronavirus lockdown has profoundly affected the instruction and evaluation processes for English as a Foreign Language (EFL) learners. Therefore, this study aims to investigate the perspectives of EFL teachers on the pedagogical barriers in online assessments. The study employed a mixed-methods approach, involving 28 participants from four different educational settings. During the qualitative phase, in-depth discussions were conducted using the Google Meet app, allowing participants to explore the pedagogical barriers associated with online assessments. The results of the qualitative analysis identified five themes of pedagogical barriers under the central category of fairness and equity: feedback, poor internet speed, learners' lack of digital literacy, online cheating, and instruction. A ranking scale was subsequently used to assess the perceived importance of these categories. The findings of this study have significant implications for EFL teachers, policy makers, and educational assessment organisations. It provides insights that can inform the development of strategies and policies to address the pedagogical barriers associated with online assessments. By recognising and addressing these challenges, educators and policymakers can enhance the quality and fairness of online assessments, ensuring a more equitable learning experience for EFL students.