There is emerging evidence that young people have a good understanding of consent as a concept, but this does not align with real world practices. The perspectives of young people on the complexities of enacting consent are lacking, as are their views on the role of sex and relationships education. This study explored the topic of consent with 18 young people aged 14-20 years through interviews conducted in South Australia. Interviews were recorded, transcribed, and coded, with four over-arching themes progressively developed through reflexive thematic analysis. Participants had a sound understanding of consent in the abstract and emphasised the importance of explicit verbal communication; however, consent was unlikely to reflect this in practice. In real-life, consent was embedded in social contexts replete with non-verbal cues, in which gendered sexual scripts dominated sexual interaction. Participants made recommendations for making formal sex and relationships education more relevant and useful.