McMaster University pioneered its Course Design/Delivery Consultants Program (CDDCP) in fall 2016. This program pairs an instructor partner who is teaching or preparing to teach a course with a student partner to obtain a student's perspective on teaching and learning in their classroom. Although the CDDCP was based on Healey, Flint, and Harrington's (2014) eight values of partnership, the contribution of other factors to its success was of interest. Participants' experiences were analyzed using a framework informed by these values. Qualitative analysis showed that these values were reflected in participants' experiences. Additionally, it was revealed that participants' experiences in the CDDCP were enhanced by two additional factors: (a) prior experiences and experiences gained through CDDCP participation and (b) the extensive program structure of the CDDCP. These findings suggest that partnership programs involving students, instructors, and coordinators should (a) explicitly acknowledge the value of participants' experiences and (b) facilitate face-to-face time among participants.