Purpose: The purpose of this conceptual paper is to make the case for the value of fostering collaborative sensemaking in responding to literature. Drawing on examples of classroom interactions in 6th-, 8th-, 11th- and 12th-grade classrooms, it proposes methods for teachers to foster collaborative sensemaking. Design/methodology/approach: Drawing on theories of "participatory sensemaking" (Fuchs and De Jaegher, 2009), transactional literary response (Rosenblatt, 1994) and "comprehension-as-sensemaking" pedagogy (Aukerman, 2013), this paper conceptualizes collaborative sensemaking to illustrate how teachers foster making sense of texts through sharing responses based on lived-world experiences, understanding the use of literary techniques and understanding events in students' own lives. Findings: Given that this is not an empirical study, there are no findings. The discussion of students' sensemaking practices in responding to classroom texts, suggests the importance of teachers creating open-ended response events in which students collaboratively support each other in making sense of characters' actions and events, as opposed to having to conform to teachers' predetermined agendas. Practical implications: Analysis of the classroom discussions suggests the importance of building students' trust in the process of sensemaking itself, fostering adoption of alternative perspectives as central to sensemaking and using activities for students' translating or rewriting events in texts to co-create texts with authors. Originality/value: This paper explores the importance of teachers engaging students in open-ended, sensemaking response events based on attending to "in-between," dialogic meanings through sharing emotions, alternative perspectives and related experiences to enhance students' engagement in responding to literature.