The plight of African American males continues throughout America and is prevalent in its educational system. Not only are these students negatively impacted by low expectations of their non-African American teachers; policy makers are impeded from devising effective strategies to improve their academic achievement. This qualitative Delphi study explored teacher preconceptions of African American male students to determine the connection between teacher expectations and the academic achievement of these students. Moral exclusion and critical race theory provided the conceptual framework. The findings of the study revealed several perceived preconceptions that included the teacher belief that these students did not care to achieve a quality education. The results provided recommendations to improve the school experience of African American male students by increasing the cultural competence of educators. While the primary recommendation was for teachers to be trained in cultural awareness and diversity; this issue proves to not be an easy fix.