This research project surveyed college students about their experiences with online learning in the aftermath of the move to Emergency Remote Teaching (ERT). Specifically, students reported on strategies they appreciate in an online instructor. While students shared varied advice for best practices, their responses confirmed what previous studies have found: especially in this moment of post-pandemic learning, students value instructors who are flexible and empathetic. Additionally, our findings demonstrate that students value engagement (with their instructor, their course content, and their peers), flexible course design, clearly organized learning management systems, and regular communication. The opinions and observations students have shared in response to our questionnaire, and the patterns across students' answers, are important for online educators to consider. This knowledge can be used to guide instructors aiming to deliver effective and engaging online courses. We recommend that instructors continue to check in with students about their learning needs and requests.