The responsibility of a teacher preparation program (TPP) goes beyond teaching future educators the knowledge and skills of the profession. It needs to provide experiences that help them succeed in the real classroom settings (GarzaRodriguez, 2019). However, there is evidence that disconnection between what is taught in TPPs and what is needed in the practical work exists. Therefore, there is an urgent need to improve the quality of these programs by constantly evaluating their quality and effectiveness. This paper reports a pilot study on pre-service teachers' perspectives about their English as a foreign language teacher (EFL) teacher preparation program in Mexico. The aim of the study was to reveal how pre-service teachers evaluated the strengths and weaknesses of their EFL teacher preparation program. Following a mixed-method, data were collected from 17 participants using an online Likert scale, adapted from Peacock (2009), and three open questions to elicit strengths and weaknesses. Findings were divided in both quantitative and qualitative. Quantitative data indicated that students were undecided or to some extent in agreement with most of the items associated with the features of the program; however, the lowest mean was shown in the areas of meeting students' needs, the balance between theory and practice and learning some practical teaching skills. On the other hand, the qualitative results showed that students' preparation as linguists and self-reflective learners as well as some subjects from the program were perceived as strengths, while the lack of teaching experience, the content, and low English language proficiency as the main weaknesses. In conclusion, though students' perspectives were still uncertain, they provided useful information to improve the curriculum.