Some research has shown that using videos in online courses can promote learner's connection to the instructor (Banerjee et al., 2020). This quasi-experimental self-study aimed to explore the impact of brief three-minute instructor-generated videos in twin segments of an online graduate teacher education seminar focused on Globalization, Communities, and Schools. Specifically, we sought to understand the extent to which the insertion of these videos influenced teacher candidates' perceptions of the dynamics of a Community of Inquiry (CoI) and their overall satisfaction as learners. The quantitative analysis of survey data using T-tests showed no statistically significant difference in overall learner satisfaction, social presence, teaching presence, or instructor social presence between the course with and without videos. However, there were significant differences in several individual items within each survey instrument. Student interviews and course evaluation comments were examined for themes revealing the strong presence of the instructor in various ways such as personalized feedback and caring tone. These findings suggest that while the videos may not have a significant impact on overall satisfaction, they do contribute to a more personalized and caring learning environment. Follow-up discussions with the instructor also revealed the reluctance to include short videos was grounded in his fear of inadvertently compromising the accessibility standards he wanted to honor--suggesting a continued need for growth in online instructors' digital competencies and additional research into the perceived obstacles of expanding modalities of online graduate teacher education.