Purpose: This paper aims to examine the extent to which students' experiences and perceptions of their literature classroom align with their teacher's instructional goals for literary inquiry and what teachers can learn from gaining access to students' perspectives on their classroom experiences. Design/methodology/approach: Thematic analyses were used to examine the data sources: mid-year and end-of-year interviews with six students, audio recordings of the teacher's rationale for her instructional designs and a reflective discussion with the teacher upon reading the student interviews three years later. Findings: Much of what the teacher intended students to get out of her instruction was what they expressed learning and experiencing in the class, yet some understood the purpose of the class to be far from her intentions. All the interviewed students had deeply personal and varied ways of relating what they learned in class to the world and their own lives. The teacher's reflection on the interviews highlighted the importance of making space for multiple meanings and perspectives on literary works. Originality/value: This paper speaks to the importance of surfacing students' individual and varied ways of making sense of literary texts as part of instruction that values students' thinking as well as the epistemic commitments of literary reading.