This essay examines writing partnerships in 2016 and 2017 that invited community nonprofit volunteers and employees into seqacib, which is a Seattle youth (middle school and high school) Native cultural literacy classroom community. As a white settler employed by the nonprofit during the events described, I emphasize the wisdom of seqacib students who reflect on the collaboration. Drawing on Rachel Jackson's work on community listening, I find that seqacib students demonstrate the importance of cultivating listening practices when community literacy practitioners enter identity-safe scholarly communities such as seqacib. I urge academic and literacy supporters in similar contexts to center Native and Native youth voices in their own terms.