We are grateful to the commentators for providing many stimulating and valuable observations. The main point of our article was to call attention to the overestimation of individual differences correlations in a subset of neuroimaging papers. To structure our discussion of these comments, we list the main points from our paper, note where commentators have agreed or disagreed with each, and provide our own reactions to their comments. [This article was printed in the in-press version of: "Perspectives on Psychological Science" (May 2009). Its contents may differ from the final published version.]