NotesFAQContact Us
Collection
Advanced
Search Tips
Showing all 5 results Save | Export
Peer reviewed Peer reviewed
Bateson, David John – Alberta Journal of Educational Research, 1995
The entire thesis of "The Bell Curve" disintegrates due to biased use of data, misrepresentations, and logical inconsistencies. Five basic flaws are: inferring causality from correlation, use of dubious racial categories, contradictory arguments concerning the immutability of cognitive ability and the relative contributions of heredity…
Descriptors: Cognitive Ability, Data Interpretation, Inferences, Intelligence Differences
Peer reviewed Peer reviewed
Reviere, Ruth – Alberta Journal of Educational Research, 1995
Criticizes Herrnstein and Murray for their lack of respect for the truth, displayed throughout "The Bell Curve"; their willingness to encourage disharmony between groups they identify as cognitively different and to foment fear and distrust of an alleged underclass portrayed as dangerous and beyond help; and their lack of interest in…
Descriptors: Blacks, Immigrants, Inferences, Intelligence Differences
Peer reviewed Peer reviewed
Wangler, David G. – Alberta Journal of Educational Research, 1995
Calls for careful but unemotional criticism of "The Bell Curve." Notes that: three chapters that deal with the IQ-race relationship have received most critical attention; genetically based racial categories do not exist; disadvantaged minority-group students have achieved success in Catholic schools with high expectations of students;…
Descriptors: Academic Achievement, Catholic Schools, Educational Attitudes, Elementary Secondary Education
Peer reviewed Peer reviewed
Belke, Terry W. – Alberta Journal of Educational Research, 1995
Neutral summary of "The Bell Curve" (Herrnstein and Murray) by a former student of Herrnstein. Focuses on the emergence of a cognitive elite in the United States; relationships between IQ and poverty, educational attainment, unemployment, divorce, illegitimacy, welfare dependency, parenting competence, criminal behaviors, and voting;…
Descriptors: Cognitive Ability, Elementary Secondary Education, Heredity, Higher Education
Peer reviewed Peer reviewed
Kirby, John R. – Alberta Journal of Educational Research, 1995
Argues that Herrnstein and Murray's cognitive stratification is not intrinsically ominous, since context determines its meaning; their "intelligence" data actually measures educational achievement; environmental effects are underestimated; and analyses and social policy recommendations are bound to the U.S. context. Concludes that…
Descriptors: Context Effect, Educational Attainment, Educational Policy, Elementary Secondary Education