Descriptor
| Comparative Analysis | 49 |
| Library Collection Development | 49 |
| Higher Education | 32 |
| Academic Libraries | 28 |
| Tables (Data) | 21 |
| Library Material Selection | 13 |
| Library Surveys | 12 |
| Library Collections | 11 |
| Scholarly Journals | 10 |
| Library Expenditures | 9 |
| Use Studies | 9 |
| More ▼ | |
Source
Author
Publication Type
| Reports - Research | 49 |
| Journal Articles | 42 |
| Opinion Papers | 5 |
| Numerical/Quantitative Data | 3 |
| Speeches/Meeting Papers | 3 |
| Reports - Evaluative | 2 |
| Tests/Questionnaires | 2 |
| Information Analyses | 1 |
Education Level
Location
| Canada | 1 |
| Nigeria | 1 |
| Saudi Arabia | 1 |
| Taiwan | 1 |
| United States | 1 |
Laws, Policies, & Programs
Assessments and Surveys
What Works Clearinghouse Rating
Peer reviewedMcCain, Katherine W. – Library and Information Science Research, 1987
Citation analysis of a systematic sample of 27 historical and historiographic articles was used to study the citation patterns of secondary sources in the history of technology. These patterns are compared with previous citation studies in history and other humanities areas and with multi-disciplinary citation studies in the social sciences.…
Descriptors: Citation Analysis, Comparative Analysis, History, Intellectual Disciplines
Smiraglia, Richard P. – Proceedings of the ASIS Annual Meeting, 1999
Random samples of works were drawn from the catalogs of the Bobst Library, New York University, and the Burke Library, Union Theological Seminary, New York to examine derivative bibliographic relationships. Two sites were chosen to allow a test of the differences in collection development patterns between a university research library and a…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Bibliographic Records, Comparative Analysis, Higher Education
Peer reviewedHolloway, Carson; Sutton, Ellen D. – Microform Review, 1990
Describes two use studies of the microforms collection at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, one conducted in 1982 and the other in 1987. Collection profiles are presented, use study methodology is discussed, and results of the two studies are analyzed and compared. (Five references) (LRW)
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Higher Education, Library Collection Development
Peer reviewedCrawford, Gregory A.; White, Gary W. – Journal of Academic Librarianship, 1999
Formulas from the "Standards for College Libraries" were used to compare the recommended collection size and number of professional librarians with the actual size of the collections and number of librarians for a random sample of Baccalaureate I and II colleges. Results revealed that significant numbers are not meeting the "Standards" in these…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Higher Education, Librarians
Peer reviewedBishop, Kay; Van Orden, Phyllis – Library Quarterly, 1998
An analysis of 599 reviews of children's books from six reviewing journals for 1995-96 was compared to earlier studies, revealing great variation in adequacy of reviews. School Library Journal provided the most complete bibliographic and ordering information but no single journal supplied all the information librarians need for purchasing juvenile…
Descriptors: Book Reviews, Childrens Literature, Comparative Analysis, Content Analysis
Peer reviewedBrown, Janet Dagenais – Reference Services Review, 2003
Compares 48 features of four versions of the ERIC database, two commercial (SilverPlatter, FirstSearch) and two free (AskERIC.org, SeachERIC.org), to determine whether features of the commercial versions were worth the cost to academic libraries. Reports results of a survey that investigated user preferences, and concludes that value added…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Databases, Higher Education
Peer reviewedMeyers, Barbara; Fleming, Janice L. – Journal of Academic Librarianship, 1991
Discussion of journal pricing and its effects on academic libraries focuses on data from the Optical Society of America's pricing study that used price per 1,000 words as a quantitative evaluative tool. Data collection methodology is described, and implications of the results for library collection development are suggested. (eight references)…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Data Collection, Evaluation Methods
Peer reviewedLeavy, Marvin D. – Journal of Academic Librarianship, 1992
A comparison of book reviews for humanities and social sciences books named to CHOICE's 1987 "Outstanding Academic Books" with a selection of books not named to the list showed no substantial difference in the number or quality of reviews received. Study suggests that libraries should be cautious in their reliance on published lists for…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Bibliographies, Book Reviews, Comparative Analysis
Peer reviewedObiagwu, Marcel C. – International Information and Library Review, 1992
Describes a study that investigated the abuse of library materials through theft, mutilation, unauthorized borrowing, and vandalism at the University of Port Harcourt (Nigeria) and King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals (Saudi Arabia). Motivations for abuse are discussed, and recommendations for improved collection protection are…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Books, Comparative Analysis, Foreign Countries
Peer reviewedBrier, David J.; Lebbin, Vickery Kaye – Journal of Academic Librarianship, 1999
Provides a methodology for evaluating title coverage of full-text periodical databases in relation to a library's print journal collection. Presents a pretest of that methodology along with a discussion of collection development principles for an effective evaluation of full-text databases. (Author)
Descriptors: Comparative Analysis, Evaluation Methods, Full Text Databases, Library Collection Development
Peer reviewedBrill, Margaret S. – Government Information Quarterly, 1990
Describes a study that used citation analysis to identify the government publications cited in international relations journals for 1964, 1974, and 1984. U.S. government, foreign government, and international organization publications and documents are compared by citation rate; implications for collection development in libraries are discussed;…
Descriptors: Citation Analysis, Citations (References), Comparative Analysis, Foreign Countries
Shaw, Debora; Park, Taemin Kim – Proceedings of the ASIS Annual Meeting, 1994
Discusses the economics and value of information and describes a study that compared an objective measure, the estimated direct costs to a library to purchase materials or provide services used by specific users, with a subjective measure, exchange values those users would pay for the information. (LRW)
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Costs, Higher Education
Peer reviewedLaFond, Deborah M.; Van Ullen, Mary K.; Irving, Richard D. – College & Research Libraries, 2000
This study conducted at the State University of New York at Albany compares methods of providing access to diverse points of view as represented by journals indexed in "Alternative Press Index." Examines local subscriptions, resource-sharing consortia that include expedited interlibrary loan systems, and four electronic full-text…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Comparative Analysis, Consortia, Full Text Databases
Peer reviewedBagnall, Roger S.; Harris, Carolyn L. – Journal of Academic Librarianship, 1987
Compares current approaches to decisions involving the preservation of library materials and describes a national project aimed at identifying and preserving important classical studies on microfiche. The use of an editorial board of scholars in this decision making process is evaluated and alternative scholarly involvement models are suggested.…
Descriptors: Access to Information, Advisory Committees, Comparative Analysis, Cost Effectiveness
Peer reviewedVidor, David L.; Futas, Elizabeth – Library Resources and Technical Services, 1988
A study at the Emory University School of Business Administration library compared the effectiveness of faculty members and librarians as book selectors. Effectiveness was measured by comparing selected titles with the Baker list published by the Harvard Business School and with business periodical reviews, and by examining circulation records.…
Descriptors: Academic Libraries, Business Education, College Faculty, Comparative Analysis


