Dominant approaches to assessment have often limited students' ability to share their perspectives on course experiences. Further, assessment approaches are often disconnected from pedagogical practice and reinforce the status quo. In this article, we outline our critical-interpretive approach to a four-year cycle of assessments examining instructor feedback in an introductory communication course. After each assessment, we adapted how we trained instructors to provide feedback. Ultimately, we utilized our assessment findings to reimagine curricula in ways that incorporate an equity-minded, iterative, and dialogic approach to provide feedback to students.