Combinatorial proof is an important topic both for combinatorics education and proof education researchers, but relatively little has been studied about the teaching and learning of combinatorial proof. In this paper, we focus on one specific phenomenon that emerged during interviews with mathematicians and students who were experienced provers as…

To further understand student thinking in the context of combinatorial enumeration, we examine student work on a problem involving set partitions. In this context, we note some key features of the multiplication principle that were often not attended to by students. We also share a productive way of thinking that emerged for several students who…

Counting problems have applications in probability and computer science, and they provide rich contexts for problem solving. Such problems are accessible to students, but subtleties can arise that make them surprisingly difficult to solve. In this paper, students' work on the Groups of Students problem is presented, and an important issue related…